Boyce is an experienced male serial dater who trawled plentyoffish.com for
several years. He shared this:

I love women of all faiths, but here’s my ranking of women’s hotness in bed by religion, from hottest to coldest:

  1. Lapsed Catholics
  2. Divorced Jewish women seeking goy boy toys
  3. Atheists/Agnostics
  4. Mainstream Protestants (Methodist, United Presbyterian)
  5. Practicing Catholics
  6. Unitarians (Too politically correct)
  7. Fundamentalist Protestants (though being a “Preacher’s Kid” helps a lot)
  8. Wiccans/Spiritualists/New Agers (Smelly … and no food in the house)
  9. Single, never married Jewish women

Notes:

There are exceptions to the above, and I have no background research on Buddhists, Hindus or Muslims. This is just my experience.

Anglican/Episcopal congregations are full of men and women who desire the negative view of sexuality of the Catholic Church … but don’t want to take the chance of possibly sitting next to poor people in church.

Lapsed Catholics along with atheists experience the least amount of guilt following a sexual encounter. Anglicans are actually really bad with post-coital guilt. This comes from British roots where the women realize they should have been closing their eyes and “thinking of England” and the men realize they should have been blowing some other British pansy.

I don’t know how large Boyce’s data set was but I’d be interested in other men’s experiences. I have my own theory about lapsed Catholic women which I may share in another post…